What is payroll fraud and how do you prevent it?
Direct Answer
What is payroll fraud? Payroll fraud is any scheme that steals money through an organization's payroll, either by paying people who should not be paid or by redirecting pay that belongs to real employees.
The fastest-growing version is payroll diversion: an attacker impersonates an employee and asks HR or payroll to change their direct deposit account. The employee's next paycheck goes to the attacker, and nobody notices until the employee asks where their pay went.
Other types include ghost employees, falsified hours or overtime, and unauthorized pay changes made by an insider.
To prevent payroll diversion, confirm every direct deposit change with the employee through a channel already on file, never only through the email, text or call that requested it.
Why This Problem Exists
- A direct deposit change is a routine request, and HR and payroll teams want to help employees quickly.
- Attackers use real employee names and titles, often gathered from public profiles, and send requests from look-alike email addresses or personal numbers.
- Requests often arrive just before a payroll run, so there is pressure to process them before payday.
- Self-service portals can be abused if an attacker obtains the employee's sign-in, often through a phishing text or email.
- The employee usually discovers the fraud first, after the money has already moved.
How It Works Today (Current State)
- Many organizations accept direct deposit changes by email or form, with limited verification.
- Some confirm by replying to the same email, which reaches the attacker rather than the employee.
- Payroll and HR teams are rarely included in phishing reporting workflows, even though they are frequent targets.
- Detection usually depends on the affected employee noticing a missing paycheck.
Better Approach (Actionable Framework)
- Require independent confirmation for every direct deposit change, using contact details already on file, before the next payroll run.
- Notify the employee through a known channel whenever their bank details change, so they can stop a change they did not make.
- Apply a short hold or review to changes made shortly before payday.
- Protect payroll self-service sign-ins with strong authentication, and watch for sign-ins from unusual locations.
- Include HR and payroll in phishing training and reporting, with examples of real diversion requests.
- For internal fraud, reconcile headcount against payroll regularly and separate the duties of adding employees and approving pay.
Key Takeaways
- Payroll fraud covers both insider schemes and outside attackers.
- Payroll diversion through a fake direct deposit change is the most common outside attack.
- Confirm the change with the real employee before payday, using a channel you already trust.
- Payroll and HR are targets and belong in the security team's reporting workflow.
Where SmishAlert Fits
SmishAlert Confirm lets payroll and HR confirm a direct deposit change with the real employee before payday, with a record of the confirmation.
When the request arrives by text or phone, SmishAlert flags the suspicious message or call so the security team can see the attempt.
See how this works for payroll and HR teams on the payroll and HR fraud solution page.